1909 : The Big Match

On August 27 1909, a match was played at Queens Royal to great acclaim.  Let’s even say it was the Greatest of All Time up to then.  Of particular interest is the fact the protagonists were women.

The event had all the makings of a memorable occasion : highly-skilled players, who were also colourful characters; a history of competition between them; an ideal setting, sure to attract knowledgeable spectators; and prestigious stakes.

The players were May Sutton and Edith Hannam.  They had played previously at Newport, with Sutton winning 9-7, 6-3.  This was considered a remarkable accomplishment by Hannam : “No one on this continent has approached this form against the world’s champion.”

The setting was Queen’s Royal in Niagara-on-the-Lake …. at the 24th annual Niagara International Championships. To get an appreciation of the position held by the tournament, read a description from that time : “The National Championship tournament in the United States will commence at Newport, August 17th, where the big players will compete.  All the stars will be in evidence and from there will come to the greatest of all tournaments, the International at Niagara-on-the-Lake on the Queens Royal Hotel courts, commencing August 23rd.  The Canadians and Americans will meet in the contests to decide the championships of the continent.”  

May Sutton had played in the final at Wimbledon in 1905, 1906 and 1907 …. winning in 1905 and 1907.  She was an extraordinary athlete.  And she had great respect for Edith Hannam, calling her “a splendid player”.

The build-up to their match was extraordinary.

 

‘Here is Where’ : The Plumb House

The Niagara Lawn Tennis Club had no public land nor public facilities, so its operations were conducted on the courts at Queen’s Royal Hotel and on the courts located at private homes throughout the Town of Niagara-on-the-Lake.

One such private home was known as the Plumb House, located on King Street where today is Parliament Oak School.  The owner of the home was Josiah Plumb, who was at the time of his death in Niagara-on-the-Lake the Speaker of the Canadian Senate.  Learning about him helps us understand the overall setting for tennis in Niagara-on-the-Lake during the 1880s and 1890s, including the close connections across the Canada/USA border and the high social profile of many Niagara-on-the-Lake residents. The online publication Parliament of Canada, includes this brief biography:

Plumb house

Josiah Plumb immigrated to Canada from New York State in 1865 at the age of 49. His Canadian-born wife, Elizabeth, was the daughter of a United Empire Loyalist and sister of Thomas Clark Street, who was both a member of the House of Commons and one of the wealthiest men in Ontario. Plumb had been a successful banker and railway entrepreneur in the United States. After the American Civil War, he retired from business and settled in the Niagara Falls area.

Prime Minister Sir John A. Macdonald became aware of Plumb’s connections and business acumen, and encouraged him to run for a seat in the House of Commons. He was successful in by-elections in December 1874 and March 1879. Three years later he was defeated, however, and Macdonald nominated him for appointment to the Senate in 1883. A Cyclopaedia of Canadian Biography noted that, as a senator, Plumb was “distinguished by his urbanity and judicial rectitude.”

Prime Minister Macdonald appointed Plumb as Speaker in 1887 to replace William Miller. Less than a year later Plumb died suddenly.

Plumb’s New York Times obituary said that he “was popular because of his Parliamentary experience, his fluency in speech, his conceded ability, and his faculty as an entertainer in the social life of which he was so prominent a figure.”

Grass Tennis Courts : ‘Elite’ or ‘Everyman’?

Few tennis players today have ever played on a grass court.  Most have never seen a grass court.  Because they’re so uncommon, the tendency is to regard grass tennis courts as very special …. expensive …. reserved for the well-to-do … even ‘exclusive’.

But from the outset, Lawn Tennis was designed to be quite the opposite …. to be, in fact, as ‘inclusive’ as possible. The notion of playing on the lawn arose from the observation that many homes had one.  Cut the grass a little shorter than usual … run a heavy roller over it to smooth out some of the bumps …. and it was ready for a net and some lines.  What could be simpler?

Tennis played in a garden setting is serene.  There’s little sound from the ball as it bounces. There’s little sound from the footsteps of the players.  Smooth and alert movements are encouraged by the uncertainty associated with many of the bounces taken by the ball. The absence of fencing encourages courtside spectating, as does the coolness from nearby trees.  Stray balls tend not to roll far in the longer grass beyond the lines.  Taken all together, it’s a pretty picture indeed, and easy to understand how the playing of the game came to be associated with pleasant social times as well : gather friends and family in the garden for some afternoon games and conversation; continue into the evening with a shared meal and some music.  Life before the electronic age.

Similar types of home-garden gatherings continue to our day, though Lawn Tennis will seldom be part of the mix.  What does continue, however, is the tradition of combining ‘tennis’ with ‘social’.  Throughout the world, wherever tennis is played, it’s most enjoyed in the company of like-minded players who forge friendships around the game.  Although tennis isn’t perceived as a team sport, it’s best played in the company of a group that functions like a team …. with players providing support to one another, showing up because they know they’re needed, encouraging and stimulating each other to maintain or improve the level of play.

A Tennis Club, at its best, is designed to replicate the feel of the old-fashioned garden party … a place to gather informally, to meet others with whom to pair up for a game, and with sufficient amenities to provide reason to linger.

Lawn Tennis was designed to be inclusive, to be for ‘everyman’.  A modern Tennis Club today achieves the same desirable outcome.

IMG_6954

This grass tennis court was constructed earlier in the summer at Hillary House in Aurora Ontario, as part of a celebration of the history of tennis in the area.  On the hottest afternoon of the season, it was a delightful place to play.

 

A Legacy for Tennis in Niagara-on-the-Lake?

A local historian was quoted recently on a proposed project in Niagara-on-the-Lake:

How would you feel if a significant part of your history is planned to be erased, as if you have never existed, never contributed one iota to the history of your people.

No one planned to erase the history of Tennis in Niagara-on-the-Lake.  Rather it faded away with time and circumstance.  At neither the community level nor the national level is a legacy to be found.  In fact, knowledge of the events that took place here is scant, and the value arising from the foundations laid here is largely unrecognized and unappreciated.

A noteworthy contrast exists in Newport, Rhode Island – location of the earliest United States Tennis Championships (now known as the US Open).  The tournament was played at Newport from 1881 to 1915.  These were the ‘glory years’ for tennis in both Newport and Niagara-on-the-Lake, and the events had much in common.  They were played back-to-back at the end of the summer, with Niagara-on-the-Lake seen as the ideal place to complete the season through the first weekend of September.

Noted tennis historian, Heiner Gillmeister, writes in his book ‘Tennis, A Cultural History’ :

In Newport, the International Tennis Hall of Fame and an annual men’s tournament on grass are today the only reminders of a glorious past.

A motivation for this blog is the need for ‘reminders of a glorious past’ for Tennis in Niagara-on-the-Lake.  Just because it has been forgotten for 100 years is no reason for it to continue to be forgotten.

1895 : The Canadian Lawn Tennis Association, and its Championship Tournament

The Canadian Lawn Tennis Association (CLTA) is known today as Tennis Canada.  It was founded in 1890 at a meeting in Toronto.

A primary responsibility of the new CLTA became the management of the Canadian Championship Tournament, which later became the Canadian Open and is known today as the Rogers Cup.  Founded in 1881 by the Toronto Lawn Tennis Club, the tournament first came under the auspices of the CLTA in 1890.  From the outset, there were ambitions to build the tournament into something more grand and expansive than had been possible at the founding club, despite the beautiful facilities offered there.  The Wright & Ditson Annual reported, regarding the 1890 Canadian Championships:

The first tournament held by the Canadian Lawn Tennis Association for the Championship of Canada began on the grounds of the Toronto Lawn Tennis Club on September 2, and concluded on September 5.  The weather was all that could be desired and the grounds were in perfect condition, reflecting great credit on the club.  Many of the best Canadian players were unable to attend the meeting, and there were fewer entries from the States than usual.

…. The championship tournament of 1891 will be held in July.  It has not been definitely decided where it will be held, but the probability is that the Toronto club grounds will be again selected, being probably the best grass courts on the continent, with the additional advantage of having two excellent cinder courts which can be used in case of wet weather.

…. A championship cup was offered for competition in singles, to be held by the winner of the tournament for one year, and if won three years successively by the same person to become his personal property.  The winner of the tournament each year will also receive a handsome prize.

The tournament was moved from early September to July, but carried on at the Toronto Lawn Tennis Club each year.  Despite the lovely facilities at the Club, the tournament was very small in comparison to the Niagara International.  The Wright & Ditson report regarding 1893:

The Canadian Lawn Tennis Association opened its fourth annual tournament on the grounds of the Toronto Club, July 25 1893 and following days. There was a list of eighteen entries – twelve from Toronto, three from the States, two from Barrie and one from Ottawa.

…. Ottawa was selected as the place for holding next year’s tournament.

Things didn’t improve much in 1894.  The Wright & Ditson report:

The fifth annual tournament for the championship of Canada, under the auspices of the Canadian Lawn Tennis Association, was held on the grounds of the Ottawa Lawn Tennis Club on July 3 and following days.  There were five entries in the ladies singles, fifteen in the gentlemen’s singles (seven from Ottawa, five from Toronto, one from Hamilton, one from Thorold, and one from Pembroke), and sixteen pairs in the gentlemen’s doubles.

But soon thereafter, the Hon. Secretary-Treasurer of the CLTA, Arthur C Rowe, was able to make a very big announcement :

It has since been decided that the next tournament is to be held at Niagara-on-the-Lake, commencing Tuesday July 9, on the grounds of the Queen’s Royal Hotel, the proprietors having very kindly placed the same at the disposal of the Niagara Lawn Tennis Club for the occasion.

… Several of the American cracks have promised to attend and they can rely on a warm welcome being accorded them by the association.

And thus we know that a Niagara-on-the-Lake Tennis Club, referred to as the Niagara Lawn Tennis Club in the records of the Canadian Lawn Tennis Association in 1894, was partner to the CLTA in the presentation of the Canadian Championships for the first time in 1895.

It was clear that if the Canadian Championships were to rise in stature and attract international players, the best way to do so was to move the event to Niagara-on-the-Lake.  It was an easy decision for the CLTA to make, given that the Niagara International had established Niagara-on-the-Lake as the feature location for world-class tennis in Canada.  The Wright & Ditson report for 1894:

The Niagara International tennis tournament will be long remembered by the Canadian tennis player as establishing a friendly entente between several leading players of the United States and Canada, who spent an enjoyable week together at the beautiful watering place of Niagara-on-the-Lake Canada.

The tenth annual renewal of the Niagara International was held on the picturesque courts of the Queen’s Royal Hotel beginning on Tuesday August 28.  It was the most expert and numerous gathering of tennis players hitherto seen on Canadian courts.

…. Tournament week at Niagara will not soon be forgotten by those who took part in it.  The dances, balls and concerts in the evening added greatly to the enjoyment, and many international friendships were cemented.  One result of the pleasant meetings at Niagara was the famous winter trip of the American College Hockey Team to Canada, in which Chace, Foote and Larned were the moving spirits, assisted by Mr George Wright of Boston.

This was followed by a reiteration of the big announcement :

During the coming season, two tournaments will be held at Niagara-on-the-Lake : the Canadian Lawn Tennis Association’s championship tournament open to all comers beginning Tuesday July 9, and the Niagara International tennis tournament beginning Tuesday August 27 and continuing until Labor Day September 2.

Could Niagara-on-the-Lake help the CLTA elevate its Canadian Championships to greater prominence?  And could Niagara-on-the-Lake and its Tennis Club support two world-class international tennis events?  1895 was to be the year to try it out.

 

1885 : Spalding’s Annuals

Two publications contain much of the documentation related to the historic tennis tournaments in Niagara-on-the-Lake : Spalding’s Annuals, and Wright & Ditson Annuals.  Here is a sample from the Spalding’s Annual of 1885 :

Screen Shot 2015-08-01 at 9.55.44 PMScreen Shot 2015-08-01 at 9.54.16 PMScreen Shot 2015-08-01 at 9.54.58 PMSpalding illustration 1885

 

The game of tennis developed at an astonishing rate over its first 10 years, and the pace of development continued year over year.  But the attributes contributing to the rapid growth didn’t change, and they remain to this day.  Among those described in this article, and valued by players today : safe; active; strategic; for women as well as for men; outdoors; environmentally friendly; inexpensive …. and “one thing that makes it exceptional” : a reliance on sportsmanship and etiquette.

The game is one that ‘has come to stay’, as it fills a void which has existed a long while, and that is, the want of a game in which ladies and gentlemen can participate, while at the same time plenty of active and not too vigorous exercise can be afforded for both, and that, too, without any element of danger to mar the pleasure of its enjoyment.

1893 : The 10th Annual Niagara International Tournament

Here is the description of the Niagara International Tournament in 1893, as laid out in the Wright & Ditson Annual :

The picturesque courts of the Queen’s Royal Hotel, Niagara-on-the-Lake, situated at the historic watering place where the Niagara River meets Lake Ontario, are annually the scene of an international tennis tournament, where players from both sides of the border and large numbers of friends and spectators gather for a week’s delightful outing.  This tournament is the oldest in Canada, being now in its tenth year, and is particularly fortunate not only in the number of its entries, but in the pleasant events, the balls, dances, and concerts, and other gayeties which enliven tournament week.  The programme offers every opportunity, including, as it does, the all-comers’ singles, open handicap singles, men’s doubles, ladies’ singles, veterans’ singles, ladies’ doubles, and mixed doubles.

The entry list for 1893 was the largest yet seen at any Canadian tournament.  The all-comers’ was won by F.K.Ward of Rochester, who had just returned from Newport, where he reached the third round.  He defeated H.Avery of Detroit, the Canadian champion, by 6-1 6-0 7-5. The challenge match for the Queen’s Royal Challenge Cup, in which Ward met A.F.Fuller of Boston, the holder, resulted in a beautiful display of tennis.  Ward’s forehand smashing with his fine backhand volleying were remarkable, while Fuller’s side line strokes and steady lobbing were unequalled.  The match was considered the finest exhibition of tennis ever seen in Canada, and was won by the young and promising player from Rochester, who is only in his seventeenth year, by the score of 8-6 2-6 6-4 6-0.

The open handicap, in which a prize was kindly presented by Messrs. Wright & Ditson, passed off most successfully.  This is the only open handicap held in Canada.  Notwithstanding the fact that the players were from distant points, so nicely were the odds adjusted that every game resulted in a close contest, Dr W.W.Coldham of Toledo (owe 40) winning the final.

The men’s doubles were captured by F.K.Ward and W.A.Boys of Barrie, the Coldham brothers of Toledo being their opponents in the finals, which resulted 6-4 6-2 7-5.

The ladies’ singles brought together for the first time the strongest players in Canada.  Miss Osborne, the Canadian champion, won from Mrs Sydney Smith of Ottawa after three hard sets by 6-8 6-3 6-3.

The mixed doubles were taken by Gordon Mackenzie (Toronto) and Miss Osborne, who defeated Ashton Coldham and Miss Coldham 6-4 6-3.

Miss Osborne and Mrs Smith won the ladies’ doubles in the finals from Miss Bernard (England) and Miss Nay (St Catharines), 6-2 7-5.

The veterans’ finals were won by Dr Holford Walker of Toronto.

The final scene in the tournament festivities took place in the ballroom of the Queen’s Royal Hotel the evening of the closing of the tournament, when, before the commencement of the hop, the prizes were presented to the successful competitors in the presence of a large company. The duty was gracefully performed by Mrs J Kerr Osborne and Mrs Winnett, who handed the Niagara International trophy to F.K.Ward, the conqueror of A.F.Fuller.  The prizes were handsome and called forth no little admiration.  The hop itself was most enjoyable and a merry throng of some 600 people were present, representing a wide range of places.  The tennis ball on Thursday evening was also a great success.

The tournament of 1894 will commence on Tuesday August 28, and will be followed the next week by the Ontario tournament at Hamilton.

 

 

Niagara-on-the-Lake has a hidden tennis history

In 1990, Tennis Canada celebrated its centennial anniversary,  and a book called Advantage Canada was published to tell the story of the first 100 years.  [See footnote.]

In 2007, on becoming president of the Niagara-on-the-Lake Tennis Club, I revisited the book and was surprised to find a section describing the significant role played by Niagara-on-the-Lake in Canadian tennis history during the period from 1885-1925.

In 2009, Tady Saczkowski became interested in the history of the Welland Tennis Club.  His research led him to the discovery that the club would celebrate 100 years in 2013, and he played a leading role in documenting the club’s history and ensuring the records would be available for the future.

Tady’s research into the history of tennis in the Niagara Peninsula also uncovered a wealth of information regarding early tennis in Niagara-on-the-Lake.  Recognizing its importance and significance for the history of tennis in Canada, his resolve is to catalog the records and photographs such that future researchers and historians will have access to them. He continues to track down new leads and accumulate new data with perseverance and resourcefulness.

I’m most appreciative of Tady’s generosity in sharing many of his findings with me.  I admire his enthusiasm for the project and would love to have the story become better known in Niagara-on-the-Lake and also within the greater Canadian tennis community.

But the task of compiling the details from such a long time period is a daunting one.  The purpose of this blog is to break it down into bite-size pieces, describing small parts of the whole as we come to understand them.  The objective is to share the stories and cultivate interest in them. Perhaps this will also lead to the discovery of other resources, hidden away in attics or scrapbooks.

And so a blog is born.

Footnote: ‘Advantage Canada’ was created at the instigation of John Beddington.  As Executive Vice President of Tennis Canada, and as Tournament Director for its flagship events, John was responsible for orchestrating the rise of the Canadian Open to the top tier of international tennis.  His impact during the 1980s and 1990s was enormous in many ways and on many fronts, among which was an appreciation for tennis history and its relevance to the modern day.  As a member of the All-England Club, and as a noted collector with an exhaustive tennis library, perhaps this came naturally to him.  But his work has left a grateful Canadian tennis community with a link to our origins that would likely not have existed without him.